Chapter five of Harvey Daniels and Steven Zemelman’s Subjects that Matter: Every Teacher’s Guide
to Content-Area Reading discusses specific tools students can use as
reading strategies. In order for students to learn these tools, they must be explicitly
taught and modeled by the teacher. Not all strategies are multi –purpose, some
are helpful at different times. For example, double entry journals are helpful
during reading, but dramatic role-play can be used before or after reading.
This chapter really encourages teachers to diversify their
strategies and gives teachers real ways to help students adapt these tools to
their own learning needs. Also some strategies might work better in some
content areas than others. Teachers should experiment with the different
strategies and find a few that seem to work well with the material and will
reach a diverse student population. Teachers should then teach and model these
strategies to their students. Ideally, students will begin to use these
strategies on their own to make sense of the material they are assigned to
read. All students can become “smart” readers if they are given the tools to
succeed.
Pre-reading activities such as brainstorming, clustering,
anticipation guides, reading aloud, dramatic role-play, and probable passage
are common strategies used in foreign language classrooms to activate prior
knowledge and link knowledge between the native language and target language.
Also, students are frequently encouraged to code in their books to help them
understand and remember what they read.Word meaning graphic organizers are also
popular to help students make the connection between related vocabulary words.
Foreign Language teachers also use lots of discussion: whole class, small
group, and partner to scaffold students reading comprehension. All of the
strategies presented in this chapter could be successfully adapted to the
language classroom.
I must admit that I feel the same as you in that some of the reading strategies were useful in more situations than others, but overall they all have thier opportunities to be useful. It is just that a few would be more helpful to students during very specific times. I enjoyed how the book outline when each specific strategy was useful. Whether it was pre-reading, during reading, or post-reading the book had a wonderful variety of strategies for the occasions.
ReplyDeleteYes! Including when to use a specific strategy so that it is effective is very helpful. Many times I'll find an activity that I like but don't really know how to make it effective in instruction.
ReplyDelete